오랜만에 쓴다.
길게 쓰다 만 글들이 몇 개 있었는데, 다른 많은 일들에 전념하고 돌아와보니 어디에 저장해두었는지도 모르겠고, 찾은들 이어쓸 수 있을지 모르겠다.
순간순간 한계를 짜내야 하는 삶 안에서 생각을 차분히 정리할 여유를 찾기가 쉽지 않다.
이따금 옛글에 "좋아요"를 눌러주시는 분들 덕분에, 내가 이전에 저런 생각을 했구나 하는 것을 새삼 상기받는다.
아이가 보통 깨는 시각보다 한 시간 정도 이른 새벽 5시에 깼기에, 머리를 좀 씻을 생각으로 저 책을 잡아보았다.
구색은 얼추 갖추었으나, 잘 간추린 책이라고는 보기는 어렵다.
127쪽에 Mary Wollstonecraft의 사망연도가 1997년으로 되어 있는데, 당연히 1797년의 오기이다. 133쪽 Phillippa Foot의 이름 표기, 135쪽 Judith Jarvis Thomson의 이름 표기도 잘못되었다(그 밖에 아주 많지만 생략).
포스트 페미니즘의 흐름을 크게 여성해방운동(MLF; Mouvement de libération des femmes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mouvement_de_lib%C3%A9ration_des_femmes)의 두 분파, 즉 '평등'을 강조하는 '혁명적 페미니스트' → 영미 페미니즘과, '차이'를 강조하는 '정치와 정신분석'(Politique et psychanalyse, 줄여서 po et psyche) → 프랑스 페미니즘으로 대별하고 있다.
그리고 포스트 모더니즘의 주요한 마디가 어떻게 페미니스트들에 의하여 재전유되었는지를 소개하고 있는데, 다룰 내용이 방대해서 그런지, 다른 '하룻밤의 지식여행' 시리즈에 비하여는 실망스럽다.
지은이 Sophia Phoca는, 런던예술대학(UAL, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_of_the_Arts_London)을 구성하는 Camberwell, Chelsea, Wimbledon의 미술대 학장님이다(https://www.arts.ac.uk/colleges/chelsea-college-of-arts/people/sophia-phoca). UAL은 Camberwell, Chelsea, Wimbledon 외에도 Central Saint Martins, London College of Communication, London College of Fashion 등 6개 학교가 연합한 종합 예술대학인데, 유럽에서는 가장 크고, QS World University Rankings 2020에서 Royal College of Art에 이어 Art & Design 분야에서 2019년에 이어 2위에 올랐다. https://www.topuniversities.com/university-rankings/university-subject-rankings/2020/art-design 3위가 미국 Parsons School of Design at The New School, 4위가 미국 Rhode Island School of Design (RISD), 5위가 미국 MIT이다. UAL은 한국에서도 유학을 많이 가(고 싶어하)는 학교이다(학생들을 인터뷰한 영상이 유튜브에 있다 https://youtu.be/lXyGLox_D04).
Phoca 학장님은 위 책 외에 특별히 남긴 저서가 없다. 대학 프로필에도 The Routledge Reader on Feminism and Postfeminism (2007)에 기여하였다는 것과, 엘렌 식수(Hélène Cixous)를 인터뷰하였다는 정도가 소개되어 있을 뿐이다.
책에서는 특이하게도 '덕 이론'(Virtue Theory)에 상당한 분량을 할애하고 있다. 너스바움 Martha C. Nussbaum이 덕 이론 계열의 신세대(?) 철학자로 분류되는 모양인데, 나는 특히, '도덕적 객관성이나 선험적 견해는 모두 허구이고, 도덕적 고려는 반드시 어떤 식으로든 이해득실과 관계가 있다'고 주장한 Phillippa Foot과, 비트겐슈타인의 제자로서 '도덕 역시 사회적 조건 속에서 구성된 것이기에 사람들이 도덕에 대한 감정적 속박, 헌신에 관하여 어떻게 느끼고 왜 그렇게 느끼는지, 즉 사람들의 동기와 욕망을 검토하여야 한다'고 주장한 Elizabeth Anscombe에 관심이 갔다. 대의명분이 정파의 이해득실을 은폐하고, 자신들과 추종자들의 정신분열을 봉합하는 알리바이로 전락해버린 시대 아닌가.
어떤 책들이 나와있는지 보자.
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/7801/87/cover150/8946061286_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/21055/53/cover150/k872636673_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/37/46/cover150/8956440093_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/42/95/cover150/8955660162_1.jpg)
책에 언급되거나 소개된 책들은 다음과 같은 것들이다. 책이 나오고도 20년이 지난 만큼, 새로 출간된 책들을 내 마음대로 덧붙였다. Juliet Mitchell의 선구적인 저서, 『정신분석과 페미니즘 Psychoanalysis and Feminism』(1974)은 언제라도 번역될 필요가 있어 보인다.
페미니즘과 포스트페미니즘
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/9188/8/cover150/0805206817_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/538/27/cover150/0873958608_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/11526/6/cover150/3034322097_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5808/34/cover150/0745300030_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/8301/26/cover150/1138146145_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/7931/11/cover150/0312013809_2.jpg)
페미니즘과 정신분석학
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/42/7/cover150/8995190345_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/11253/2/cover150/8991729312_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/15/33/cover150/9788934804888.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/4/36/cover150/8974185318_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/234/10/cover150/8990787874_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5858/0/cover150/0946439494_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5477/41/cover150/0631183477_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/20182/60/cover150/1526125161_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/24132/82/cover150/0520329392_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/19457/36/cover150/1138602949_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/13627/97/cover150/1501727745_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/4413/39/cover150/113883470x_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/8529/49/cover150/1349479586_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/125/38/cover150/0465046088_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/7931/96/cover150/0394714423_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/3577/25/cover150/113878818x_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/141/43/cover150/1560232811_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/531/64/cover150/0820419990_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/175/84/cover150/0674004035_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/525/66/cover150/0801499712_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/175/48/cover150/0674002075_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/507/21/cover150/0520206304_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/500/5/cover150/0300067690_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/530/10/cover150/0814780199_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/529/97/cover150/0814712525_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/4639/8/cover150/0415073588_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/3941/76/cover150/0816617724_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/103/79/cover150/0394757300_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5242/65/cover150/0801492351_1.jpg)
문화 연구와 문학 연구, 탈식민주의
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/134/1/cover150/0415280125_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/146/32/cover150/080203800x_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/163/1/cover150/0415374138_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/172/59/cover150/0415900379_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5390/53/cover150/904203453x_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/6679/43/cover150/1138187801_2.jpg)
성, 퀴어 이론 등
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/109/68/cover150/0813519381_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/img/noimg_off_b.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5849/23/cover150/0853157553_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/110/16/cover150/0415905192_1.jpg)
영화 연구
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/13728/85/cover150/8998937778_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/8848/15/cover150/k532535191_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/2039/0/cover150/8992151454_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/4/88/cover150/8988089014_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/8/72/cover150/8979413009_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/img/noimg_off_b.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/7722/34/cover150/0719099560_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/173/10/cover150/0415074673_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/11050/67/cover150/1138500933_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/8916/27/cover150/1138149748_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/115/7/cover150/0816629137_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/106/45/cover150/0253204747_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/11767/43/cover150/0520088794_2.jpg)
예술 연구
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/4654/85/cover150/0879236329_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/1875/91/cover150/8930104274_1.jpg)
무용
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5695/58/cover150/0333476263_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/896/28/cover150/0415111625_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5790/78/cover150/9057020254_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5694/27/cover150/0333596676_2.jpg)
사상가별[이번 포스팅의 맥락상 지나치게 일반적(?)인 책들은 제외하고, 덕 이론 사상가들을 위주로 포함시켰다].
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/13/10/cover150/8932431019_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/13/10/cover150/8932431027_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/10783/5/cover150/8949716097_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/10783/17/cover150/8949716100_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/18274/86/cover150/3955101177_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/18183/89/cover150/3854097603_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/555/91/cover150/1572411651_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/168/21/cover150/0878204601_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/125/37/cover150/1559212853_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/25450/93/cover150/8932920516_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/25453/54/cover150/8932920613_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/20268/66/cover150/k382635959_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/2024/46/cover150/8990985900_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/30/62/cover150/898038095x_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5365/18/cover150/8991706886_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/20110/97/cover150/8957336354_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/8448/5/cover150/899129071x_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/22/15/cover150/8930606113_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/17/8/cover150/8980384238_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/39/69/cover150/8988105613_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/16834/32/cover150/893743881x_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/140/99/cover150/0520254066_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/104/33/cover150/0140172327_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/82/88/cover150/s282636999_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/23450/51/cover150/8935664820_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/19436/74/cover150/k252635512_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/497/11/cover150/0198750056_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/17712/9/cover150/1788360044_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/7721/75/cover150/1845408969_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/819/35/cover150/0199603359_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/509/25/cover150/0521785103_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/6562/79/cover150/0415708575_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/910/25/cover150/1439266352_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/23004/25/cover150/3668986789_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/529/11/cover150/0812696581_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/158/11/cover150/0199282803_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/513/73/cover150/0691114730_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/3259/12/cover150/0262525623_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/109/23/cover150/0674749499_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/172/41/cover150/0674769813_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/7152/64/cover150/0801410509_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/7492/6/cover150/8930614116_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/img/noimg_off_b.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/6116/41/cover150/1781955476_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/1142/18/cover150/1441145427_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/497/51/cover150/0199561842_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/119/52/cover150/097536622x_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/155/60/cover150/1585678236_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/104/81/cover150/0460877216_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/1537/62/cover150/1903933706_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/533/54/cover150/0826473237_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/514/48/cover150/0715631411_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/495/81/cover150/0192805002_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/111/78/cover150/0631190198_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/897/57/cover150/0631142576_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/4506/55/cover150/0520037243_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/1153/47/cover150/0415675987_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/img/noimg_off_b.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/13170/47/cover150/1350051071_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/9260/1/cover150/1474298001_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/7886/54/cover150/1138141720_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/7043/55/cover150/1138127019_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/3131/68/cover150/1844657922_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/1188/4/cover150/0415610249_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/711/8/cover150/184465253x_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/137/90/cover150/1845400801_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/153/2/cover150/0415378486_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/111/18/cover150/0415346428_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/164/19/cover150/0415371392_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/1527/73/cover150/0415304490_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/134/93/cover150/0415289874_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/504/75/cover150/0415278333_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/175/48/cover150/0415133785_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/120/21/cover150/0820320412_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/504/60/cover150/041513224x_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/173/46/cover150/0415107733_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/504/51/cover150/0415028302_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/14220/37/cover150/3319797107_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/3518/21/cover150/1107698340_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/1184/60/cover150/1616144939_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/559/3/cover150/159102689x_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/157/63/cover150/1591024587_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/153/38/cover150/1591024226_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/126/38/cover150/1591023599_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/123/83/cover150/0226311376_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/498/10/cover150/0226311341_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/104/27/cover150/0521293294_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/25100/22/cover150/8925589818_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/24377/78/cover150/8964621409_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/21108/47/cover150/896735665x_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/17683/88/cover150/k012534722_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/11380/16/cover150/8964621018_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/13680/66/cover150/8954648959_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/8983/96/cover150/8958203900_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/7536/99/cover150/8964620658_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5686/88/cover150/8971996978_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/6343/37/cover150/8955593856_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5479/89/cover150/8937431548_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/3159/55/cover150/8958202599_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/42/13/cover150/8987519880_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/19789/29/cover150/k182635032_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/101/69/cover150/8961950029_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/55/45/cover150/8986114771_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/44/87/cover150/8956440387_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/37/34/cover150/8980382480_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/52/28/cover150/8980388152_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/98/20/cover150/8992214197_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/156/81/cover150/0415324335_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5544/1/cover150/9089646760_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/18635/7/cover150/1789141222_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/152/26/cover150/1861892632_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/139/26/cover150/1403992460_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/114/32/cover150/0253210194_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5720/77/cover150/0719075556_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/3176/94/cover150/3638952754_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/24790/59/cover150/8936478141_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/22946/8/cover150/1788738624_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/14010/72/cover150/1478001615_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5699/25/cover150/0415752310_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/877/96/cover150/0822350815_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/901/45/cover150/0801494435_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/178/3/cover150/0415972280_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/532/50/cover150/0822331020_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/532/50/cover150/0822330385_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/532/41/cover150/0822319187_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/499/1/cover150/0253209366_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/498/60/cover150/0231066112_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/507/24/cover150/0520219414_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/4655/11/cover150/0941920097_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/5281/39/cover150/8973813935_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/87/97/cover150/8960900052_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/87/97/cover150/8960900044_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/512/21/cover150/0631149317_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/103/83/cover150/0631163395_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/1525/74/cover150/0140124861_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/504/50/cover150/041501400x_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/103/83/cover150/0043510728_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/4537/69/cover150/113800068x_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/107/83/cover150/0231066597_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/103/81/cover150/0936756020_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/294/60/cover150/8954607365_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/7018/47/cover150/080149396x_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/109/23/cover150/0679741011_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/4506/28/cover150/041504930x_2.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/4817/25/cover150/0374535477_1.jpg)
![](https://image.aladin.co.kr/product/4189/22/cover150/1138821756_1.jpg)